The Best Payroll Services of 2023

Choosing the Right Payroll Services

Comparing payroll companies can be overwhelming with all the new technology and legal ramifications linked to payroll. Pricing, of course, is a primary consideration for small business payroll services. So is customer service with changing workforce environments.

The right business online payroll provider should offer a range of plans, features, and services to grow the business and stay compliant. Take the time to review and compare services offered. Review the costs of optional added features. Look for flexibility to meeting the changing work environment.

Ask as many questions as possible. Involve your staff and gather their concerns and information about problems they encounter with the payroll system. Listen to their comments about what they are currently experiencing.

Payroll management is critical to operating a business online payroll. Small business owners have several options to effectively managing this essential process without error. This online payroll feature can improve a company’s response time efficiency to an employee’s inquiry.


  • Overview
  • Description
  • Brand/Store
  • Availability
  • User Rating
  • Review
  • How other 3rd Party Experts Rank each product (Bronze, Silver, Gold)
  • PCMag
  • Nerd Wallet
  • Business.org
  • Fundera
  • Neil Patel
  • Business.Com
  • QuickSprout
  • Fool
  • Business News Daily
  • Price
  • Base Pricing
  • Elite Pricing
  • Premium Pricing
  • Customer Service
  • 24/7 Accessibility
  • 24/7 Customer Support
  • Online Chat 24/7
  • Payroll Standard Features
  • Automated Features
  • Benefits Tracking
  • Check Printing
  • Direct Deposit
  • Email
  • Employee Tracking
  • Garnishment Feature
  • Mobile
  • Pay Contractors 1099
  • Workers Comp
  • Payroll Add on Features
  • 3rd Party Integrations
  • Background Checks
  • Consulting Services
  • Expense Intergration
  • Full Service Payroll
  • Health Benefits
  • HR
  • Time Attendance Tracking
  • Unlimited Payroll Runs
  • Reporting
  • Business Tools
  • Custom Reports
  • Export
  • Importing

What is a payroll service?

If the enterprise has employees, employers are obligated to pay part-time and full-time employees in the form of checks or direct deposits less the traditional withholdings and payroll deductions.

The purpose of payroll services remains the same — to compensate an employee for work performed on behalf of the business. Thanks to technology, how the company’s payroll is processed has changed, offering small businesses a choice of payroll services. Today, payroll companies offer options that include technologically enhanced payroll services to manage and control the entire payroll process for small business.

For employers to meet payroll and tax compliance, small business or large business payroll calculations must be accurate. Why? The final computations are the summation of the employer’s state and federal tax filings required to be reported to the appropriate regulatory agency as scheduled.

As the company grows and increases its employees, the process becomes more complicated and time-consuming — driving the company to search for the best payroll service. Here’s where payroll companies enter the picture having a long history of supporting payroll functions for small and large enterprises. Their expertise and knowledge of processing and handling filings have helped organizations maintain their legal responsibilities to employees, state and federal governments, and the company’s financial infrastructure.

As a result, small business payroll companies have grown into a competitive marketplace as enterprises seek the best payroll service to meet their employee and employer obligations.

Workings of a Payroll Service?

Payroll services for a small business are automated online payroll services. The plan features include calculating employee paychecks, payroll registers, generating quarterly and annual payroll reports and processing employer tax deposits and payments.

Online payroll services allow small business owners to take advantage of payroll services and technological expertise. This partnership provides a hidden benefit that prevents processing errors and keeps the enterprise in good standing with the state and federal governments.

Internally payroll services make sure the coordination between the organization’s payroll administration and Human Relations (HR) policies are compliant, offering another hidden benefit for the organization.

Depending on the company’s need payroll services for small business include self-service or full-service. A review of payroll compliance guidelines can help with the selection of payroll services needed. You might be surprised to discover the updates of modern payroll processing.

Enterprises can start with basic service packages or customize a plan that works best for the company.

Online Payroll Services Features Boosting Accuracy

Today, small business online payroll plans offer the best payroll software packaged plans that include business online payroll features. The best payroll services provide easy access to payroll platforms for small business payroll services, tailoring software to fit the organization’s operations and budget.

Payroll companies have raised the level of internal payroll performance and efficiency for small business. Besides processing and managing business online payrollpayroll providers have developed integrated systems that allow employees to access their records online. Employees can easily get answers to frequently asked payroll questions.

The best payroll service includes platform security controls protecting confidential information and personal data. That same security embraces online payroll services and mobile access for management and administrators.

For many small businesses, third-party professional accounting consultants are hired to help with the company’s payroll process. Online payroll services can be a cost-effective strategy for small business payroll using third party professionals allowing better controls to company confidential payroll data.

Payroll Providers vs. In-house Payroll Services

A significant advantage of working with payroll providers is their knowledge and experience. It helps to reduce the stress and learning curves associated with small business payroll services. If you measure your time involved in solving in-house payroll processes, trouble-shooting software, or dealing with government agencies — operating expenses escalate.

While owners are doing business, payroll providers are staying up to date with the latest payroll services pertaining to small business, laws, and regulations — helping to keep the company fully compliant. Along with payroll updates, online payroll services allow enterprises to scale during seasonal peaks without any disruption to normal business operations.

For companies that have outgrown their existing payroll systems, payroll companies have adapted platforms to help transfer payroll data. Online payroll services can integrate features from the current system helping to streamline payroll operations.

Companies choosing to stick with in-house payroll processing often find that updating the latest software can be costly and time-consuming. Costs are always the first consideration, yet the online payroll service costs are minimal when it is time to update and improve payroll process functions. Modernizing operational tasks always helps small business to reach higher performance levels.

Mobile Workforces Set New Online Payroll Trends

Decisions are part of doing business. Some are easy, while others leave enterprises contemplating the value of change. The company’s response or needed action is tied to where the business is heading based on the company’s business strategy.

The challenge is to make sure the enterprise picks the right small business payroll services for the company’s payroll operations. A good starting point is to determine the company’s payroll needs — consider the business size and the current and future types of workers. The question of the day — can the company afford not to meet the payroll compliance?

Listed below are payroll concerns that help make a good business payroll decision. These questions are responsible for generating efficiency for the company. Without an honest opinion of the status, they could prevent the company from reaching its business goals.

  • Are the current payroll systems and operational functions sufficient to proceed and thrive?
  • How long has the company been struggling with outdated payroll processes?
  • How much time is spent on monitoring and research to authenticate the company’s payroll and tax compliance?

These days, business online payroll, good management, the latest technology, and expertise are all significant elements to business success. Automation upgrades have introduced automation intelligence (Al), increasing efficiency throughout the entire payroll process with accurate speed. This feature is essential with the recent remote employees working for a single employer.

As part of the payroll process, Al accurately identifies the workforce through compliance classification — employee versus contractor — preventing employers from wrongful classification regarding tax obligations. Violations, even by accident, can be costly.

Review Summaries

Check out our Top Picks
9.2Expert Score
Gusto Payroll - Editors Choice Winner

When it comes to the payrolling industry, there are not many companies out there like Gusto. Gusto is a extremely popular platform for business owners to outsource their payrolling and has even been named one of the best platforms online today.

Price
8.5
PROS
  • According to numerous surveys, and their website, Gusto has been said to be easier to use than any other payrolling platform or solution.
  • Gusto Payroll Services provides business owners with a comprehensive full-service payroll features.
  • You can find all the information you need on their website, including fees and prices at gusto.com
  • Business owners may sign up for a one month free trial.
CONS
  • Gusto does charge a per person fee.
8.9Expert Score
Paychex Payroll

There are not many companies that can compete with the streamlined process of Paychex Payroll Service. This company has risen to the top of the payroll industry as one of the best online payroll services because of it’s unique features, fast payroll process, and user-friendly nature. Aside from the minor fees for processing W-2 forms and 1099s, Paychex is most certainly worth your company’s consideration.

Price
8.2
PROS
  • Paychex Payroll Services offers 24/7 customer service support.
  • Paychex system allows employees to access their personal information through the self-service portal and application.
  • Paychex’s system makes payroll easy and only a few easy steps, which may be beneficial for business owners that are not tech savvy.
CONS
  • You will be charged a fee to process any 1099 or W-2 forms.
  • Paychex is a more simplistic payroll service and may not offer all the bells and whistles of more prominent companies.
8.8Expert Score
OnPay Payroll

Today, there are dozens of programs and software that are designed to help manage and control a company’s payroll and tax services. An example of this is a prominent and nationally-recognized company, OnPay Payroll Services. We are going to explore this top-rated payroll service company and decide whether this company is worth your consideration.

Price
8
PROS
  • OnPay Payroll Service provides business owners with a tax accuracy guarantee. This way, business owners are ensured this program will handle a company’s taxes with no errors or mistakes.
  • OnPay Payroll Service offers a quick and speedy payroll service, ensuring all employees are paid on-time and accurately.
  • OnPay provides a wealth of payroll features at considerably affordable monthly costs.
CONS
  • To utilize OnPay’s direct deposit feature, business owners will need to pay a monthly fee.
  • OnPay will also charge a nonmail fee to process W-2s and 1099 forms.
  • Whenever a company hires a new employee, OnPay has a new reporting fee.
8.7Expert Score
Intuit Quickbooks Payroll

Intuit Full Service Payroll is clearly a full-scale payroll company, offering a great and feasible payroll option for business owners. It’s clear that this company has been named one of the best companies on the market for a reason.

Price
8.5
PROS
  • Intuit Payroll Services comes with error-free guarantee when handling employee checks and taxes.
  • Intuit offers one of the most comprehensive payroll service packages available for business owners.
  • Intuit Payroll services will help set-up and establish your company’s payroll system.
CONS
  • Intuit Full Service Payroll does not come with 24/7 customer support.
  • This service may not prove useful for larger companies.
8.6Expert Score
ADP Payroll

One of the most widely used payroll service company and service in the United States is ADP Essential Payroll. This workforce management service company has risen to the top of the class given its comprehensive solutions for business owners. With ADP, business owners, of any size company, can take care of payroll and tax services with their all-in-one program. In this article, we are going to explore ADP and see if the hype is worth your future business investment.

Price
8.5
PROS
  • ADP Enhance Payroll does not charge fees for payroll services for employees in multiple or different states, making this a great company for larger multi-state companies.
  • ADP Enhance Payroll is one of the most comprehensive services available to businesses today.
  • Business owners have access to both payroll and tax services with ADP RUN.
  • ADP Enhance Payroll has won numerous awards as one of the best online payroll services for business owners.
CONS
  • Unlike many other major payroll companies, ADP does not provide business owners with an account specialist.
  • ADP Enhance Payroll Service programs are not user-friendly and make require some time to learn how to use.
  • Negative

The pros and cons of a payroll service

At some point, growth, budget, and legal considerations play a critical role in choosing payroll services for small business. The challenge for small business enterprises is finding the best payroll service that can support a growing company’s need for online payroll services.

Although it may be part of the learning curve, small business enterprises finding themselves struggling with payroll responsibilities to meet compliance and management commitments. Traditionally designated payroll employees are responsible for processing in-house payroll with a moderate understanding of the regulatory compliance.

Answering the call to assist are payroll companies with the latest technology in the marketplace. Each is competing for a highly targeted market segment — payroll services for small business. For business online payroll companies to succeed, payroll providers need to understand your online payroll services expectations.

Yes. Small business payroll comes with a cost for engaging online payroll services — today’s changing work environment makes this choice well worth the effort. Let’s take a look at the pros and cons of choosing a payroll provider for the business.

Efficiency improvements within payroll operations

All businesses go through a growing phase; juggling multiple tasks can be daunting, time-consuming, and costly. Small businesses need to consider how much time could be saved by updating with automated payroll services.

Payroll functions include calculating employee compensation, year-end tax issues, retirement contribution funds, management reports, regular, overtime and vacation benefits to unemployment claims.

The largest cost-effective savings for business online payroll services is better use of work hours, allowing owners to focus on other areas of business operations associated with business growth and increased revenues.

Payroll compliance to government agencies

Another area where business online payroll services can assist enterprise operations is state and federal payroll — requirements must be met — there’s little room for error, and forgiveness is non-existent. The most common mistake linked to payroll compliance is inaccurate data gathering and record keeping.

Employee classification, followed by missing timesheets causing an interruption of scheduled pay frequency. The error is eventually caught, generating a hard copy check as a viable solution. The action caused duplication of payroll processes — this repetitive expense can be costly for the company.

Payroll companies are experts at payroll compliance, offering services that include coordinating payroll functions with the enterprise’s Human Resource policies. The goal is to manage and prevent an employer’s legal risks related to payroll.

Managing penalty for late tax filings

In order to file quarterly or annual taxes employers need to process and file a volume of payroll forms on time to avoid penalties.

Here is another area where payroll expertise is available. Payroll companies for small business keep track of the calendar deadlines for tax filings. They routinely inform small business of the upcoming payments based on the payroll data and information.

Missing a deadline can create serious cash flow issues for enterprises, with penalties reaching 15 percent. Because payroll providers are familiar with the process, they are well versed in the available options for working with regulatory agencies.

Improving small business payroll productivity

As the business grows and the employee count increases, payroll providers offer user-friendly platforms for business online payroll services. New administrators have immediate access to payroll tools and resources at their fingertips to manage recordkeeping on wages, benefits, contributions into retirement programs, and taxes.

The best payroll software is designed to perform payroll services for small business, simplifying the payroll process using automation. The automation features help to improve poor productivity, generally associated with missed deadlines and calculation errors.

Generally, a lack of payroll tools and reliable resources is the reason for low productivity. Armed with the latest payroll management processes, missed deadlines and inaccurate data accumulations become a thing of the past.

Weighing the benefits (pros) against the challenges (cons) is part of making a good business decision.

Most payroll providers have scalable small business payroll services, allowing enterprises to grow at their own speed. On the other hand, some business online payroll service plans are inclusive with specific features. In this case, businesses may find that they are paying for services not needed at the moment.

Small businesses need to review each plan and payroll service for features that best fit the company’s business strategy and its current budget.

Security makes the top of the list for most enterprises doing business online. As the remote workforce dig their heels in — security access to employee information from pay to company benefits demands a secured online entry.

Understanding the payroll providers commitment to compliance

Payroll errors occur even with the best of payroll companies — human intervention overshadows technology errors. Armed with knowledge and experience, payroll providers support, inform, and guide small business online regarding payroll compliance.

In the event that the information provided by the enterprise is incorrect and filing procedures proceed, discovery of the error after submission has repercussions.

Payroll services for small business carry service responsibility, the enterprise responsible for the payroll owns the liability to compliance. Payroll compliance refers to how an organization adheres to rules, laws, and regulations for payroll that include accurate calculations, recorded and verifiable compensation practices of online payroll services.

Small business responsibility for inputting accurate data

Companies transferring their payroll process to payroll providers need to be prepared in terms of payroll management and the financial cost of payroll services. The most common reason small businesses choose to work with online payroll services is to ensure the accounting system is organized, trackable, and accurate.

The changeover process of payroll services for small business involves time and details, assuring the information entered is accurate and up to date. Setting up online payroll services is a managed process involving the company’s participation.

Payroll security measures

Most enterprises are aware of the potential risks of poor security and take for granted all systems are alike when it comes to security protection. Do not assume all payroll companies are equipped to protect your data.

Reputable payroll providers have the proven experience when it comes to securing a company’s information and data. As a critical feature for online business, security measures are consistently updated to support and protect payroll services as the business grows.

When choosing a payroll provider, consider the cost of losing confidential information and personnel data. Ask questions about the payroll security measures and controls in the event of business disruptions.

Supporting remote workforces

As the workforce moves from inner offices to remote locations, small business enterprises need to consider business online payroll services for conducting business operations. The selected payroll provider must be capable of supporting multiple state locations.

Did you know that some states monitor and regulate weekly and bi-weekly payments?

This workforce strategy also brings up another challenge on software capabilities for linking mobile and computer devices. Here again, consider the cost of installing the software internally compared to taking advantage of the feature for a minimal fee through payroll companies.

Payroll services for small business offer various features that make day to day management of your business and employees efficient, cost-effective, and more productive. The final decision comes down to how small business payroll works for the enterprise and its employees. 

Best Online Payroll Service Companies: Full Service for Small Business
Logo
Compare items
  • Total (0)
Compare
10